Keighley Ann Alyea's alleged killers will go to trial

Thumbnail image for HILT_DUSTIN.jpg
Dustin Hilt
Thumbnail image for MATTOX_JOSEPH.jpg
Joseph Mattox
The three men accused of killing 18-year-old Keighley Ann Alyea will go to trial. 

Fox 4 appeared to be the first to deliver the gruesome details of Alyea's killing. Fox 4 reported that the three men beat 18-year-old Alyea, who begged for her life, and then 18-year-old Dustin Hilt allegedly stabbed her in the stomach.

Alyea disappeared in the early hours of September 30, 2009. Her body was found October 5 in a farm field in Cass County, Missouri.
  
Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Keighley Ann Alyeafilephoto.jpg
Keighley Ann Alyea
Thumbnail image for CALBECK_GERALD.jpg
Gerald Calbeck
Fox 4 also reported that Gerald Calbeck, 18, and Joseph Mattox, 22, confessed to the killing. The hearing apparently filled in many of the blanks of what happened that night. Detectives testified that the three men beat Alyea and believed that they had killed her and put her body in the trunk. Alyea reportedly started hitting the trunk and calling for help.

After hearing the pounding, the men stopped on a gravel road and asked her if she'd tell on them. She promised not to and begged them to take her to a hospital. Detectives testified that Hilt stabbed her in the stomach with a hunting knife and Calbeck kicked her in the head. Detectives said Alyea had been stabbed a total of 29 times (at least nine to the chest) and also suffered wounds to her head and neck, according to Fox 4.

As far as the confessions, Fox 4 reports:
Mattox told police that Hilt wanted to hurt Alyea and take her car, but never mentioned murder as part of the plan. But Calbeck told investigators it was Mattox who mentioned wanting to kill Alyea and who first attacked her with a metal jack handle in the back of her car as they drove her around.
Hilt was reportedly Alyea's ex-boyfriend, and their relationship was allegedly abusive. Hilt and Alyea had each other's names tattooed on their bodies, but Alyea's father had said Hilt's name would be removed before Alyea's funeral.

Hilt, Mattox and Calbeck are charged with first-degree murder, aggravated kidnapping and aggravated robbery.
  • Weekly
  • Music
  • Promotions
  • Dining
  • Events